Visit us at our locations along the Connecticut Shoreline in Guilford and Madison. We'd love to meet you!
And subscribe to our newsletter to learn about new product arrivals, special events, exclusive subscriber discounts and more!
All Shy Creation items are hand set and all stones are natural and hand-picked. Each piece is unique and you can expect slight variations in the shade, hue, and tint of the color stones.
All product sales are final. Per store policy, we do not offer returns.
Water Street Jewelers is a Connecticut jewelry store offering fine jewelry, custom jewelry design, engagement rings, and expert jewelry repair services. Visit our stores in Guilford, Madison, and New Haven to explore curated collections of gold jewelry, diamonds, gemstone pieces, and distinctive designs. Whether you’re looking for a gift, designing a custom piece, or restoring an heirloom, Water Street Jewelers provides knowledgeable service and beautifully crafted jewelry meant to be worn and loved for years.
Opening in 2026
We are excited to announce the opening of our new location in New Haven.
We'll see you there!
Are you ready to Propose?
Find the perfect ring with our Engagement Ring Buying Guide!
Give the Gift of Choice!
Gift Cards are available for purchase online or in store.